Caseware vs Silverfin: Which Offers Better Value for Accounting Firms (2024)

Accounting firms continually seek ways to streamline operations, improve accuracy, and add value to their client experience.

However, the challenge lies in selecting the right tools. Caseware and Silverfin claim to help firms achieve these goals, but which truly delivers?

Below, we’ll explore the strengths and weaknesses of both accounting platforms, helping you determine which offers better value for your firm.

What is Caseware Cloud?

Caseware Cloud is a cloud-based accounting management platform designed to handle various aspects of business operations for accounting firms.

It offers a suite of tools to improve efficiency in tasks such as file management, scheduling and workflow automation. The platform is mainly known for its robust features in audit and tax, providing comprehensive tools for financial reporting and compliance management.

Caseware is a popular choice for firms that require detailed audit and tax functionalities. It offers a range of features to support comprehensive financial management.

What is Silverfin?

Silverfin is cloud-based software designed to improve consistency and create capacity for accounting firms through automation and real-time data insights.

It provides a comprehensive solution for centralising client data. streamlining compliance processes, standardising workflows, and

One of Silverfin’s standout features is its AI-powered tool, Silverfin Assistant, which continuously analyses client files to detect anomalies, missing transactions and advisory opportunities. This proactive approach helps firms improve accuracy and deliver higher-quality services.

Read More: Reputation at Risk: Why Delaying Your Firm’s Accounting Cloud Migration is a Reputational Timebomb

Caseware vs Silverfin: A Quick Comparision Guide for Accounting Firms

Selecting the right accounting software is crucial for optimising efficiency and accuracy in your firm. This guide compares Caseware and Silverfin, highlighting their strengths and differences to help you make an informed decision.

Ease of Use, User Experience and Onboarding

When evaluating accounting software, ease of use and user experience can significantly impact your team’s productivity and user satisfaction.

CaseWare

According to reviews on G2, Caseware users often report a steep learning curve. They mention that the interface needs to be more user-friendly for new users and that they struggle to find specific features.

Additionally, importing data from outside sources into Caseware can be cumbersome, adding to the frustration and challenge of using the platform effectively.

Unfortunately, poor user experience (UX) comes with a high cost. The experience accountants have with their tools can greatly impact their job satisfaction, productivity levels, and your firm’s bottom line.

For example, Avon Products Inc. gave up on a $125 million software overhaul after it was revealed that the software was so difficult to use that it was causing salespeople to quit.

Silverfin

Silverfin, on the other hand, is designed with ease of use at its core. The platform features an intuitive interface that simplifies even the most complex accounting processes.

New users can quickly get up to speed, reducing training time and boosting productivity. Silverfin’s user-friendly design ensures that all features are easily accessible, streamlining workflow and enhancing user satisfaction.

The emphasis on a seamless user experience helps firms to operate more efficiently and effectively from day one, leading to better adoption and utilisation across the firm.

But don’t take our word for it. Here’s how implementation and onboarding went for Baker Tilly, a large accounting firm with six offices and over 160 employees.

“With change, you always get some resistance,” says Pieter from the firm’s IT department. “Often people first have to experience for themselves that the new system is more efficient, but of course, you only see that when you actually use it.”

Yet, in the case of Silverfin, that turned out particularly well compared to other systems already implemented at Baker Tilly in the past. “Exact Online, for example, is something we have been using for six years. But I think we only had everyone onboard and using the tool 5 years late,” he recalls.

Read More: The Hidden Cost of Excel in Accounting: How Spreadsheet Dependence Fuels Burnout

Features and Functionality

Evaluating accounting software’s core features and functionality is essential to understanding how each platform can meet your firm’s specific needs.

Caseware vs Silverfin: Audit and Assurance Capabilities

Renowned for its comprehensive audit tools, Caseware provides robust audit trail features, detailed audit templates, and extensive compliance management, making it a preferred choice for firms focusing heavily on audit and assurance tasks.

While Silverfin offers strong compliance capabilities, its primary focus is enhancing workflow efficiency through automation, real-time data and AI-powered analysis rather than specialised audit functionalities.

For example, Caseware features a centralised risk tracking system that allows for detailed management and reporting of risks and controls, which are integral to audit processes.

Caseware vs Silverfin: Automation and AI

Silverfin excels in automating compliance processes and using AI-powered tools like the Silverfin Assistant to proactively analyse data, detect anomalies, and identify advisory opportunities while maintaining high-quality integrity.

For automation, Silverfin shines among Caseware alternatives with its standardised working paper templates. These templates use best practice layouts to automatically pull real-time data from your data hub and can automate various reconciliations and calculations. They reduce the time spent on file preparation and ensure your team only works with the most up-to-date information, enhancing efficiency and accuracy across your firm.

Caseware, on the other hand, only offers basic automation for financial reporting. For example, it can help mitigate risks of data inconsistency and improve formatting accuracy by enabling automatically drafted financial statements.

Read More: The AI Advantage: Why AI and Accountancy Goes Hand in Hand

Caseware vs Silverfin: Data Analytics

Caseware IDEA is a powerful data analytics tool primarily focused on providing audit data insights.

It offers:

Audit-Specific Analytics: Designed to help auditors analyse large datasets for anomalies, fraud detection, and compliance issues.
Advanced Analysis: This includes capabilities such as data visualisation, statistical sampling, and custom script development for detailed analysis.
Integration: Integrates with various data sources, enhancing its utility for audit purposes.

Silverfin Insights offers a broader range of analytics capabilities for accounting firms. It provides a more comprehensive and proactive approach to data analytics, extending beyond audit-specific insights to encompass overall financial health and advisory opportunities for clients.

Real-Time Data Analysis: Provides real-time analytics across all client data, helping firms gain insights into performance, trends, and anomalies.
Comprehensive Reporting: Delivers powerful reporting tools that allow firms to generate detailed financial reports, KPIs, and benchmarking data.
Proactive Advisory: Utilises AI to identify advisory opportunities, helping firms offer proactive advice to clients and demonstrate their value beyond number crunching.
Integration: Seamlessly integrates with major bookkeeping systems, ensuring comprehensive data coverage and consistency.

Customer Support and Training

As mentioned earlier, Caseware has a higher learning curve. Users must make time for live training or self-study courses.

However, depending on the learning levels, these courses will cost your firm $150 to $500, and the live training will cost between $225 and $850.

While it’s great that there is an extensive knowledge database, the training tiers highlight how complex it is to learn how to use the software, and it’s not included in the base price.

Silverfin takes a different approach to training and support. With dedicated Customer Success Managers and a comprehensive knowledge base, Silverfin ensures that users receive the assistance they need to maximise the platform’s potential.

During the rollout, Silverfin provides a Customer Support Manager who will provide documentation, how-to videos, and weekly check-ins to ensure smooth adoption. In addition to an extensive knowledge base and video and face-to-face training options, your firm has access to “in-app” guided tours to help new users navigate Silverfin at their own pace.

Here’s a quick glimpse of how training happened at Baker Lilly:

“On the advice of Cedric, our Customer Success Manager, we followed the Silverfin onboarding process,” says Alexandra, one of the key users from Baker Lilly. “After that, we gradually involved more and more people in the implementation.”

There was also internal training on how the tool works and, at a later stage, a joint Q&A where employees could ask questions. “The colleagues know they can come to me with their questions,” says Alexandra, “and if I don’t know it myself, I can always turn to Cédric.”

Silverfin Stands Out Among Caseware Alternatives

When comparing Caseware and Silverfin, it’s clear that Silverfin offers several advantages that make it a more compelling choice for accounting firms. With its user-friendly interface, powerful automation and AI features, real-time data syncing and excellent customer support, Silverfin meets and exceeds the demands of modern accounting firms.

Ready to experience the benefits first-hand? Request a demo with Silverfin today and see how it can enhance your firm’s efficiency, accuracy, and client satisfaction.